Navigating the social environment of the women's locker room
Dorrance describes his efforts to nurture collective respect in the socially complex environment of the women's locker room. First, he seeks to publicly identify different players with different roles, trying to foster team chemistry. Second, he carefully, and often privately, praises his best players, wary that public praise might turn their teammates against them. At the heart of these tactics is an effort to nurture personal relationships with his players so his praise builds their self-esteem and does not make them targets for criticism for fellow players.
Citing this Excerpt
Oral History Interview with Anson Dorrance, June 11, 1991. Interview L-0054. Southern Oral History Program Collection (#4007) in the Southern Oral History Program Collection, Southern Historical Collection, Wilson Library, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill.
Full Text of the Excerpt
- MARY JO FESTLE:
-
How do you observe that the relationships are important on the team? I
understand how you stress the competition on the field and that
that's okay. How do you then take the other side of that?
What's important to them?
- ANSON DORRANCE:
-
Well, what we do as much as we can is I always try to share stories about
different women on the team doing things for other women on the team. We
try to create an atmosphere of rewarding the unique environments where
it happens. And it happens enough for us to constantly talk about it.
The way I guess we officially talk about it is, we talk about it during
a game; not all eleven players are going to play their best. I mean,
there are going to be some games where one player is going to play
poorly. So it's our function as a team to make sure we carry
her. And what I share with them about team athletics that I prefer to
individual athletics is team athletics, in my opinion, is all about
basically carrying the ones that aren't playing as well that
day, because some day, they will eventually carry you. And
that's a philosophy we try to carry over into sort of
everything. Everyone has a function. You know, the
worst player on the team still has a positive chemistry function. And we
talk about those functions of the different players that maybe
don't contribute during the game that have a genuine concern
for different people on the team and we try to talk about those sources
of qualities. And so what we try to nurture is a collective respect for
anyone who cares about anyone does something for any of them. And we
always review that every chance we can. And we try to review it in a
very, very humorous, but serious way. We don't want to become
maudlin about our attachments to each other, so we always try to throw
in a lot of humor. But by the same token, we want them to know that that
sort of behavior is very positive and that's what
we'd like to see. And it makes a difference. It makes a
difference.
- MARY JO FESTLE:
-
I've heard that your teams are pretty close. Is that true?
- ANSON DORRANCE:
-
Yes and we try to foster that, although it's a never ending
struggle because in a bizarre sort of way, I think women have a
tremendous capacity for affection for each other, but by the same token,
they have a tremendous sensitivity about, I guess, everyone's
weaknesses. Women's weaknesses are reviewed more by women
among themselves about each other than men's weaknesses are
reviewed about themselves. And in a way, the more threatening the woman
is, the more critical everyone is of her. And so the women that are
threatening, obviously, are the ones who get the most attention, the one
that's the star or something. And so being a star on a
women's team is a very, very difficult position for her to be
in because obviously she wants to be the best she
can, but she knows that by becoming exceptional, in a way,
she's torn apart by everyone around her, which is really
bizarre. With the men, it's the opposite to a degree. I mean,
if there's a great performance by a male, one of things you
can do to bolster his success is to sort of talk about it in front of
the group. And everyone pats him on the back and they think
it's great and there's no problem. The last thing
you can do with a very successful woman is to basically highlight her
success in front of her peers because, first of all, she
doesn't like it at all because she knows what's
happening. If you highlight her success in front of everyone else,
everyone just tears her apart. It's a very difficult position
to put a woman in. And that's one of the lessons I learned
very early in my coaching career. So now, what we do to develop
self-esteem among the top players is to praise them privately and
it's really bizarre. It has a tremendous effect from two
points of view. One, it develops your relationship with her which is
vital because your success as a coach is going to be based on how
successfully you negotiate all the individual relationships you have and
it has to be individual. When you coach men, it can be a collective sort
of leadership and camaraderie and can be general and they can sort of
respect you and be distant from you. And you can still be very
successful. With the women, you can't. It's got to
be very personal and your relationship with them is affected the more
personal the relationship can get. And obviously, there's a
boundary there you have to draw eventually. But it's a
boundary you want to get very close to because the more personal your
relationship can be with her, the more
effective she's going to be by, you know, following things
that we'd like her to do. And so, by praising her personally
it has a more positive effect than praising her in front of the group.
Whereas, it's funny, praising men personally has almost no
impact because they know they were great and they're not
interested in a closer relationship with you. So to praise them: water
off a duck's back. They'd rather have you praise
them in front of the group or in the press. And so, what will happen if
you keep praising him personally, he'll think
you're weak and he'll take all your praise for
granted and he won't really consider you as a source for his
self-esteem. But a woman will really feel very good about it and feel
that she does have a unique relationship with you that's
different from everyone else's which builds her self-esteem.
Because then she considers herself unique and special and not
threatened, which is what would occur if you praised them in front of a
group. All these things make a difference when you're trying
to build the chemistry of the two teams, the men and women.