Female sexuality and soccer
Dorrance describes his role in improving the image of female athletes. He thinks that the "attractive women" he recruits help revise many people's beliefs that women turn to sports because they have no romantic interests to fill their time. He believes that one women's basketball coach who recently declared that she would not recruit lesbians was employing a clever recruiting strategy, because fearful parents would respond well to it. He disagrees, however, with the premise behind the coach's announcement: that young women might become gay by associating with other gay women. As he concludes his thoughts, he briefly comments on the need for male coaches of female players to be very careful not to enter an inappropriate relationship.
Citing this Excerpt
Oral History Interview with Anson Dorrance, June 11, 1991. Interview L-0054. Southern Oral History Program Collection (#4007) in the Southern Oral History Program Collection, Southern Historical Collection, Wilson Library, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill.
Full Text of the Excerpt
- MARY JO FESTLE:
-
I guess soccer would not be a sport that one would immediately think of
as feminine. And certainly you're encouraging the players to
be extremely aggressive. I've seen them play and
they're incredibly tough. Is that a concern for you? Is it
ever a concern for the players?
- ANSON DORRANCE:
-
I think by the time I get the players it's not a concern
anymore. They went through that catharsis in high school when they were
either being shunned or excoriated for being aggressive. So, by the time
I get them that's not a psychological issue anymore for me.
That's one of those junior high issues when, you know,
puberty starts to kick in and they start to realize maybe who they are
and what direction they are going in. Those are issues that maybe junior
high coaches and high school coaches have to deal with. I
don't, because obviously, women I
recruit have proven themselves in this arena and it's not an
issue for them. One thing I do think we have contributed towards,
though, is a lot of girls we end up recruiting here obviously, are the
sort of girls that I'm recruiting because I'm not
only interested in winning, but also promoting the image of the school
and the sport. I think we have some very attractive women. I
don't think that stigma is ever going to be thrown in our
direction. But by the same token, we've had some very average
looking women that have competed here and succeeded and that are still
involved in athletics, so I think we have a balance. Maybe
it's conscious to a degree and maybe again, it's
just a sacrifice I'm making to make the game more popular. I
almost think it's positive for us to bring in these women
that are attractive to basically, bury that old stereotype that you
know, if you're a woman and you compete in athletics
it's because you can't go out on a date. I mean,
it fills your afternoons, where you would have basically spent them boy
chasing if you had a shot. But since you don't have a shot,
you've poured yourself into athletics and that's
where we want you to remain. You know, that's a very negative
stigma. And I think for awhile in women athletics, that was the case.
And maybe in the way I am, I guess, building this team up.
It's certainly not conscious, but obviously there is some
sort of subconscious influence because the teams I've had, I
think, are great teams but they're attractive and we look
good getting off a bus. I think it's to bury that stigma
because it is still a stigma in some sports.
- MARY JO FESTLE:
-
And I've seen in the news recently, I think it was a woman
basketball coach, sort of letting out the word that she would not
recruit lesbians.
- ANSON DORRANCE:
-
Yeah, was that at Penn or Penn State?
- MARY JO FESTLE:
-
I think one of those.
- ANSON DORRANCE:
-
Yes. I heard that on tour. And that's very clever recruiting
because what you're recruiting, you're not really
recruiting the player, you're recruiting the parents. And
obviously, lesbianism isn't something we address. I mean, we
understand it's a part of women's athletics and
you know, the lesbians I've had on my teams have been great;
great players, great for chemistry, very positive role models in my
opinion, but you can never come out and make that sort of statement
publicly because you would be destroyed by it. I mean, all the religious
zealots out there would make mincemeat of you. I was reading in the
paper today the Presbyterians, I guess, won't push through
this new stance on pre-marital sex and bringing in gay and lesbian
preachers. Now, I don't know anything about the Presbyterian
sect except this didn't go through. And I'm sure
the reason it didn't go through isn't that it
wasn't a positive step. It's just that the public
reaction would be so negative toward their church that they would suffer
as a result. people in my opinion are sort of
narrow-minded and one-dimensional. I forget where I was going. Oh, the
thing with Penn State. I think that's clever recruiting. Was
it a woman?
- MARY JO FESTLE:
-
Yes.
- ANSON DORRANCE:
-
Okay. All parents of young athletes are aggressive and have this fear
that their daughters are gay or are going to be. And I think this is a
way to sort of let the parents know, "If you send me your
daughter, I'll convert her," as if such a thing is
possible, which is absurd. Everything I've read about it and
my understanding now is I think your sexuality is on a continuum from
rampant heterosexuality to rampant homosexuality with bisexuality being
in the middle and you're dropped somewhere on the continuum.
And to a degree, your environment takes you in one direction or another,
but if it takes you in a direction away from your natural genetic
predisposition, you're not going to be comfortable. And so,
in a way, if these parents of this girl that's sort of on the
border or maybe even a bit gay, is sent to this school to be converted
into being a heterosexual, I think you're doing her a
disservice if she spends her whole life confused and unfulfilled and you
know, nervous. And so, I don't know whether or not
that's necessarily a good thing. But it's great
recruiting. I mean, it's clever. She's going to
get a lot of good players and she's going to win over parents
who have this fear watching their daughter grow up and become a lesbian,
you know. "Oh, gosh, she's a lesbian because we let
her play softball last summer," or something. "Oh,
God, it's our fault." So I think that's
clever in one perspective, but I think it's dishonest from
another. I don't think that coach has an understanding about,
I don't know what it's called. Gender
predisposition? I don't know what the formal term is, but I
think she's missing the boat.
- MARY JO FESTLE:
-
I guess one advantage that you have being a male coach is that you
don't have to deal with, "Is the coach a
lesbian?"
- ANSON DORRANCE:
-
Yes, but then you've got the other thing which I think is even
worse. I think the greatest challenge for men coaching young women is,
you know, there's a sexual line you can't cross,
and it's crossed constantly because let's face it.
A lot of the girls that come in, especially into a high visibility place
like this have a tremendous respect for you. And you know, these mentor
relationships, they're bent out of shape to a degree anyway.
It would be an environment that would be easy to exploit and so if you
don't have that as a stigma, you've still got the
other thing that is something you've got to be very careful
about. I think one of the worst things about men coaching women is that
line that's crossed. It's not so much you have to
be careful, but you do. And it's not one sided.
It's not just coming coach to player. So, you know, there are
issues you've got to deal with from that perspective that,
obviously, the female coach wouldn't have to deal with.