Dear Sir
of
Brunswick, the Valedictory, and two othe Speeches
to the nearly equal to the Latin, to three
next best who were members of the
Dialectic Society,2 and
as it respects the Intermediate honors we rank equal to the
Dis. in number. No report perhaps since the
establishment of the
College, has excited such discontent between the
members of the two Societies. The
Dis. who calculated on getting both the Latin, &
Valedictory, being sadly disappointed, in their sanguine expectations, have
attempted, almost to excite a rebelion. They have met and sent in a petition to
the Faculty, to be exempted from speaking at commencement, which, more than
probable will be granted to them. Being furthe dissatisfied, because some of
their members were ranked before others who ought not to have been, they
divided themselves into three distinct bodies for the support of their several
favourites but finding this to be productive of too much [j]aring [and] party
spirit among themselves, they at lengthheld a
Corcus, (which has become quite a common procedure in the
U.
States) and nominated the most popular candidate, whom they have
resolved to support under all circumstances.3 But
these means have finally proved abortive, and ineffectual, and they have become
quieted and contented.
Dr
Caldwell
sets out the 4th of May for
Europe, he
is to be furnished by the
Trustees with 6, or 8 thousand Dollars for the
purpose of purchaseing a Philosopical Apparatus and Books for the
University Library, he intends visiting a good
many of the principals to[wns] in
England.4 The
Phis. have been straining every nerve
[unrecovered] as much money as possible, to send on by
[f]or Books, and [I] expect we will be able to
[unrecovered] a very ha[ndsome] sum. I shall flatter [my]self
with the idea [of en]joying your presence, at commencement, and [hop]e you will
not let any trivial occurence prevent y[our] comeing. You must
write write me the news in
Brun and let me hear from the ellection. Give [my be]st
respects to
Mrs Jones and
Cousin
Jack, [unrecovered]
Binns, tell him he must write to me, that [I am] anxious
to hear from
Mr Babitt, and his sch[ool.]I [am] yours most respectfully
/Percival,s Post Office/
Brunswick/
Va." "[Pr]Mail"
appears in the lower left corner. The postage endorsement reads "Chapel
Hill/April 12th} 18 1/2." The letter is written
on the recto and verso of a single sheet of paper, folded to create an
envelope. Several holes on the left side of the sheet make recovering some
words in the last fourteen lines of
Harrison's
letter impossible.
died shortly after receiving
Harrison's
letter. The
Philanthropic Society minutes for July 28, 1824,
record that "Mr Harrison
introduced the following
motion, viz. I move that the members of the
Philanthropic Society be requested to wear crape on
their left arm for three weeks in commemoration of their brother members—
Will
Twitty and
Thomas Jones
, which passed" (Vol. S-8, UA).
reports, "The highest honor men of the class
of 1824 were
Edmund D. Sims
, of
Virginia;
Matthias Evans Manly
,
Thomas
Dews, and
William Alexander Graham
. . . .
Sims
spoke the Latin Salutatory,
Manly
the Valedictory,
Dews
the Mathematical Oration, and to
Graham
was assigned the Classical oration" (1:296).
Manly
,
Dews,
and
Graham
were members of the
Dialectic Society;
Sims
, a member of the
Philanthropic Society.If the letter "written from the University" refers to Harrison'sWhereas it has been stated by a member of the Dialectic Society to a member of the Philanthropic Society that the members of the former body have conclusive evidence to believe that a letter or, letters have been written from the University stating 1st that the Dialectic Society as a body had resolved to oppose the report published by the Faculty of the University respecting the present Senior Class and 2nd that the Philanthropic Society were glorying in the disgrace of the Dialectic Society; And whereas these two assertions said to be contained in a letter written from the University, do not express the opinion or the feelings of the Society therefore I move that the following motions be adopted by the Philanthropic Society. 1st It is resolved by the Philanthropic Society, that the said Society does not believe that any measures have been taken or any resolutions adopted by the Dialectic Society to oppose the report relative to the present Senior Class lately published by the Faculty of the University.—II. It is resolved by the Philanthropic Society that if any unfortunate event had occurred to the Dialectic Society—the Philanthropic Society would deem it not only ungenerous but dishonorable to exult in any manner on the misfortune of the Dialectic Society, the members of the two societies being fellow Students of the same institution and for the most part natives of the same state. III. It is resolved by the Philanthropic Society, that it is due both to the Dialectic Society and to the feelings of the Philanthropic Society to disclose that the Philanthropic Society knows of no reason why the word (disgrace) should at all be applied to the Dialectic Society and that the Society disclaims all idea, or desire of so applying the word. (Vol. S-8, UA)
April 20th letter to
Jones
, then
Harrison
may have been an instigator of the flap over the
commencement honors.
set out for
Europe in
Spring 1824 and was gone for almost a year. The trip was necessary because
books were cheaper in
England
and on the
Continent than in
America.
Caldwell
also argued that overseeing personally the
purchase of the philosophical apparatus—an astronomical clock, a transit
instrument, an astronomical telescope, and other scientific equipment and
supplies—would ensure that the best parts, for the best price, would be
used. The
trustees awarded him $6,000 for the purchase
of books and scientific equipment. The apparatus cost $3,361, and the
979 books
Caldwell
purchased brought the total to $7,238.01.
Caldwell
paid the excess but the
trustees reimbursed him (Battle 1:294).