Hon. Sir,
No doubt but the papers have made you acquainted with our proceedings at
Chapel Hill. They
have been such as will excite a lively concern throughout the state. The
University seems destined to experience many trials. The desertion
of the Students however, at this time portends its ruin. Every friend to science
must lament the injudicious conduct of the
Trustees in passing so odious a law. If
the
Institution does perish, and I sincerely hope it may not, it is to
be ascribed alone to the pernicious influence of that law. It was very
objectionable in theory, but much more so in practice. It banished all harmony.
The consequence of every return of the Monitor was contention between the
Students and the Teacher, and the Students & the Monitors. Frequently
have I heard the return of the Monitors contradicted in the Public Hall, tho he
was acting upon oath. What young man of feeling would be willing to place
himself in such a situation as this? Who would suffer himself publickly to be
called a perjured villain? And a Monitor
Page 2
certainly
does this when he permits the correctness of his returns to be questioned. When
our Remonstrance was presented to the
Trustees, they consented to take off
the oath, but substituted a promise no less binding, and introduced some
provisions into the law, which made it much more objectionable than it was
originally. Upon examination it will be found that the Monitors have cognizance
now not only of the conduct of their particular classes, but of the whole
school. Thus a Member of the lowest class can admonish and return a member of
the Senior or Junior Classes. And is it not degrading to put a young man of the
first standing in College under the absolute control of a little Boy —
a Boy that may be incapable of discriminating between proper and improper
conduct? It certainly is. I could say much more on this subject, but I will
postpone it until an opportunity offers of doing it personally. And perhaps, an
apology is due to you for troubling you with this letter. If so, I beg that you
will ascribe it to the uncommon solicitude that I feel to satisfy my friends as
to the part which I have acted. If they condemn me, it is my misfortune to be
condemned
Page 3
for doing what I conceived to be
right and proper.