Well, by this time the United States Supreme Court had developed some
new constitutional doctrines about voting rights, particularly the
general right that every qualified citizen is entitled to one vote, one
person, one vote. A number of decisions about equality and fairness in
voting rights. Under those doctrines it was crystal clear that the
double voting system that I've described was unconstitutional. I don't
think there was much question about it, but we had a lot of difficulty
establishing it. The first thing we did is we went to the legislature to
try to get some help. There was only one member of the Robeson County
delegation who supported us and that was Joy Johnson. Joy Johnson was a
black member of the legislature, and the blacks didn't, as I say, have a
great interest in this double voting issue, but Joy Johnson supported us
a thousand percent, which I thought was great. I remember one of the
nicest experiences I had in the legislature, I met a senator there named
Wade Smith. Wade Smith continues to be a good friend of mine. He's a
fine, excellent lawyer in Raleigh and he was very supportive of us as
well. He was very concerned about the situation. Generally speaking on a
matter of particular local interest the legislature
will defer to the local delegation, though. With Joy Johnson being the
only local legislator who would support us, we were unable to get
legislative relief. So we turned to the courts. We filed a lawsuit in
the United States District Court for the eastern district of North
Carolina. The case came before the Honorable Algernon L. Butler as I
recall. Judge Butler turned us down. So we had to appeal, and we went to
the United States Court of Appeals for the fourth circuit, which sits,
holds argument in Richmond, Virginia. I remember the day up there very
well. We were suing the Robeson County Board of Elections and the State
Board of Elections. The Robeson County Board of Elections was
represented by an attorney from the Attorney General's office. Excuse me
the State Board of Elections was represented by the Attorney General's
office. The local Robeson County Board of Elections was represented by
Mr. Britt who later became a federal judge in the United States District
Court for the eastern district of North Carolina where he served with
distinction and is now I think on senior status. But we argued the case,
and a great number of Indians, both Tuscarora and Lumbee, came up to
Richmond for the argument and filled the courtroom. It was quite an
exciting event because the court was very open and fair-minded. It was
very clear from the argument that they saw the unconstitutionality of
the double voting system, and it was really a very euphoric occasion. I
think we were very confident after the argument based on the comments of
the judges, and after the argument we went outside and kind of
celebrated. Bruce Barton took some pictures, wrote a nice story in the
Carolina Indian Voice about the argument. I remember, though, feeling
kind of sad about one thing, which is the only person who could talk to
the two groups at the time, the Lumbees and the Tuscaroras, was myself.
Well, I guess at the time Bruce Barton was still
welcome in both groups, but shortly after that the Tuscaroras stopped
talking to him. So his front-page story about the argument had two
photographs of the group there, one photograph of Lumbees with me in the
middle and one photograph of Tuscaroras with me in the middle. They
insisted on being photographed separately, which I thought was
unfortunate.
But I might tell you a little story I guess. This was a little story
about when we filed the lawsuit. You asked about the AIM folks. So maybe
I can back up a little bit and tell you when we decided to go forward
with the lawsuit, I had been working with the Lumbee group that I
described to you. But as I was working on it, I began working with some
of the Tuscaroras as well. They became supportive. So I actually had
separate meetings with both groups. I met in Pembroke at a restaurant as
I recall with a huge number of Lumbees, and I presented the draft of the
complaint to them and got their support. While we were meeting, Russell
Banks [actually, Dennis Banks] and another Indian from the AIM movement
came to the meeting and spoke. I kind of waited until they finished, and
they left, and I spoke to the group again, and I said—I don't remember
exactly the words—but I essentially said I don't think you need to take
to the streets. I think we have legal remedies available. I'd like you
to support this lawsuit and see if we can begin getting legal remedies.
I think this is the way to proceed. Most people I think supported that
effort. I know there were some people who supported the AIM movement. I
know there were some actions, barn burnings, I remember, and other
things attributed to the AIM folks. I think about this time there was a
big sit-in at the Department of Education in Washington as I recall or
at one of the departments in Washington. I think it was largely the
Tuscarora group that was involved in that. I then
had a meeting with the Tuscarora group. This time we met out in a rural
part of Robeson County in a large one-room building, and there were a
good number of people. I would say there were a good hundred people at
that meeting. At the time the chief of the Tuscarora tribe was a guy
named Keever Locklear. See, Keever had been one of the people arrested
in the sit-in in Washington. At the time Keever and I didn't know each
other very well. Since then we've become very good friends. But on that
date, in front of this assembled group, I began talking about the
proposed lawsuit, and then I read them the complaint. I read paragraph
one of the complaint, and I said, "The plaintiffs are a group of Lumbee
Indians from—" And I didn't finish the sentence when I felt myself
grabbed from the behind and wheeled around a knife at my throat. There
was Keever Locklear holding the knife and several of the other
Tuscaroras were surrounding me. "What have I done wrong? What is this?"
Well, things calmed down in a little bit, and I learned that I had used
the term Lumbees, and that's when I learned that the Tuscaroras thought
that that name was the source of all their problems.